I Used to Think I Was Bad at Prayer

Learning to Offer God My Attention Again

Image by Aritha from Pixabay

I used to think my difficulty with prayer was a character flaw.

I couldn’t stay focused. My mind wandered constantly. Silence felt loud and uncomfortable. I would sit down with the best intentions and feel scattered within seconds. I assumed this meant something was wrong with me. Maybe I wasn’t disciplined enough, holy enough, or trying hard enough.

What I didn’t realize for a long time was that my attention had been quietly trained elsewhere.

Not by anything dramatic. Just by the ordinary rhythms of modern life. Constant input. Endless scrolling. Always a little noise, a little stimulation, a little interruption. I was very practiced at reacting and consuming, and increasingly out of practice at staying present.

Once I started noticing that, something shifted. Not overnight, and not perfectly. But enough to make me realize this wasn’t just a prayer problem.

It was an attention problem.

We tend to think of attention as something passive, something that just happens while we go about our day. But attention isn’t neutral. It’s an act. A choice. And whether we realize it or not, we are always offering it to someone or something.

What we attend to is what we slowly become shaped by. That’s why attention isn’t just a productivity issue or a personality quirk. It’s a spiritual resource, finite, valuable, and quietly formative.

Attention as an Offering

We understand offerings instinctively. We give time to people we love. We show up. We listen. We stay present.

Attention works the same way. When we give God our attention, especially in prayer, we are offering Him the most honest thing we have. Not eloquent words. Not spiritual ambition. Just presence. And presence, as any relationship teaches us, matters.

When our attention is scattered, restless, constantly pulled elsewhere, prayer doesn’t stop working, but it does change. It becomes thinner, shorter, more distracted, less receptive.

Not because God demands better focus, but because relationship requires presence.

Fragmented Attention Changes Prayer

Most of us don’t struggle with prayer because we don’t care. We struggle because our attention has been trained to fracture.

We sit down to pray and immediately notice how loud the silence feels. How quickly our thoughts jump. How uncomfortable it is to stay still. We assume this means we’re bad at prayer.

But what if it simply means we’re very good at being interrupted?

When our days are shaped by constant input, scrolling, reacting, and consuming, prayer can feel foreign. Not because it’s difficult, but because it asks for something we rarely practice anymore: sustained presence.

Scripture Requires a Different Kind of Attention

Reading Scripture isn’t like consuming content. It doesn’t reward skimming. It doesn’t optimize itself for engagement. Scripture asks us to linger.

This is why it can feel dry or difficult. It doesn’t lack life, but it refuses to perform. Fragmented attention subtly teaches us that only things that entertain us deserve our focus. That’s not a neutral lesson.

It shapes what we expect from God.

Distraction Is Spiritually Formative

Here’s the part we often miss: distraction doesn’t just steal our attention; it forms us. What we practice attending to trains what we notice, what we value, and how patient we are with depth. When we rarely attend fully to anything, we slowly lose the ability to recognize depth when it’s present.

We become impatient with prayer. We rush conversations. We skim our own lives, and we tell ourselves this is just the way things are.

Attention and Love Are Closely Linked

To love someone well is to attend to them. Not constantly, not obsessively, but intentionally. A distracted presence feels like absence, even when we’re physically there. We know this because we feel it when it’s done to us. Have you ever tried talking to someone who continually checks their phone?

God does not demand our attention. He waits for it.

And when we learn, slowly, imperfectly, to offer it again, something changes. Not because we’ve suddenly become holy, but because we’ve become available.

Reclaiming Attention, Gently

This isn’t a call to digital purity or heroic discipline. It’s an invitation to notice.

Notice where your attention goes automatically. Notice what interrupts your prayer most quickly. Notice what feels hardest to stay present for.

And then, gently, practice staying. A few minutes longer in silence. One paragraph of Scripture read twice. One conversation without checking your phone.

Small acts. Deep formation.

Because what we give our attention to shapes our inner life, and if we want more peace, more presence, more love, this is one place to begin.

Attention isn’t just how we focus. It’s how we love.

With grace,

---

PS: If you want to go deeper, The Practice of the Presence of God is one of the most encouraging and inspiring books I have ever read on the topic of prayer and focus. It is super-short, super-simple, and yet profound. It stays with you. It was also recently recommended by Pope Leo!